[Mystic Mock]

I'm saying Manga just to be catchy (and the fact that I have initially picked all Manga's to face each other) but eventually Western Comics, Manhua & Manhwa's will be welcomed to the fold.

Basically I've picked twelve Mangas to read, and each round I will be scoring each individual chapter out of ten.

So basically Round 1 will be each Manga's first chapter, with Round 10 being each series 10th chapter.

Obviously when new series get added along they'll be behind the original ones on this list in terms of how many chapters that I've actually read from them.

And here's the criteria of each score.

10 - Masterpiece
9 - Great
8 - Very Good
7 - Good
6 - Fine
5 - Average
4 - Bad
3 - Very Bad
2 - Terrible
1 - Appalling
0 - Beyond Evil Towards Humanity

I am going to try my best not to just throw 10's out for the series that I really love, as I feel like 10's should be earned for a thing like this to work.

Here's the links to each of the series Wikipedia pages that will be showcased on this thread:
In case any of these series might catch your fancy.

Ayashimon - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ayashimon

Vagabond - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vagabond_(manga)

Billy Bat - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billy_Bat

The Promised Neverland -
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Promised_Neverland

One Piece - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Piece

Pluto - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pluto_(manga)

Ice-Head Gill - https://ice-head-gill.fandom.com/wiki/Ice-Head_Gill

Monster - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monster_(manga)

The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_...uild:_Red_Hood

Fabricant 100 - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fabricant_100

Zombie Loan - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zombie-Loan

Vampire Knight - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vampire_Knight

Sadistic Beauty - https://koreanwebtoons.fandom.com/wiki/Sadistic_Beauty - Obviously not for kids.

Blade: Blood Allies - https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Blade_Vol_2_1

Weakness - https://myanimelist.net/manga/158754...ness&cat=manga - Not for kids.

Blame! - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blame!

Martial Master Asumi - https://martial-master-asumi.fandom....ter_Asumi_Wiki

When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine - https://www.anime-planet.com/manga/w...-crazy-heroine - Not necessarily for kids.

Toy xx Box - https://www.anime-planet.com/manga/toy-xx-box - Not for kids.

Spice Girls - https://myanimelist.net/manga/86045/...irls&cat=manga - So far nothing really sexual in this series.

Talk Dirty To Me - https://www.anime-planet.com/manga/talk-dirty-to-me - Not for kids.

Lilith - https://myanimelist.net/manga/125093/LILITH - Not for kids.

Ex-Arm - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex-Arm

Love Only The Body - https://www.anime-planet.com/manga/i...y-love-my-body - Definitely not for kids.

Superman: Red Son - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superman:_Red_Son

The Horizon - https://webtoon.fandom.com/wiki/The_Horizon

Final Fantasy: Lost Stranger - https://finalfantasy.fandom.com/wiki..._Lost_Stranger

Baroque: The Missing Paradigm - https://myanimelist.net/manga/3915/B...ku_no_Paradigm

After War Gundam X - https://myanimelist.net/manga/20221/...%20x&cat=manga

I know that this is a weird thread, but I hope that people will enjoy it regardless.

I've read four chapters of each Manga so far, so here it goes.

And to clarify even if two Manga series get the same score, I am still saying them in the order of preference for that particular chapter, I'm not doing a "in no particular order" type of thing. Basically ties are being separated in placing.

Round 1:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
2. Zombie Loan - 7/10
3. Vampire Knight - 7/10
4. Vagabond - 7/10
5. Fabricant 100 - 7/10
6. Monster - 6/10
7. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 6/10
8. Pluto - 5/10
9. Ice-Head Gill - 5/10
10. One Piece - 4/10
11. Ayashimon - 4/10
12. Billy Bat - 2/10

Round 2:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10 (Non-Mover)
2. Vampire Knight - 7/10 (+1)
3. Ayashimon - 7/10 (+8)
4. Billy Bat - 7/10 (+8)
5. Vagabond - 7/10 (-1)
6. Zombie Loan - 7/10 (-4)
7. Pluto - 6/10 (+1)
8. Monster - 6/10 (-2)
9. One Piece - 6/10 (+1)
10. Fabricant 100 - 6/10 (-5)
11. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 5/10 (-4)
12. Ice-Head Gill - 5/10 (-3)

Round 3:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10 (Non-Mover)
2. Zombie Loan - 7/10 (+4)
3. Ayashimon - 7/10 (Non-Mover)
4. Vampire Knight - 7/10 (-2)
5. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 6/10 (+6)
6. Pluto - 6/10 (+1)
7. Billy Bat - 6/10 (-3)
8. Vagabond - 6/10 (-3)
9. Monster - 6/10 (-1)
10. Ice-Head Gill - 6/10 (+2)
11. Fabricant 100 - 5/10 (-1)
12. One Piece - 5/10 (-3)

Round 4:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10 (Non-Mover)
2. Zombie Loan - 8/10 (Non-Mover)
3. Billy Bat - 8/10 (+4)
4. Vampire Knight - 7/10 (Non-Mover)
5. Monster - 7/10 (+4)
6. Ayashimon - 7/10 (-3)
7. Vagabond - 7/10 (+1)
8. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 6/10 (-3)
9. Fabricant 100 - 5/10 (+2)
10. One Piece - 5/10 (+2)
11. Ice-Head Gill - 4/10 (-1)
12. Pluto - 3/10 (-6)

Round 5:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10 (Non-Mover)
2. Zombie Loan - 8/10 (Non-Mover)
3. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 7/10 (+5)
4. Fabricant 100 - 7/10 (+5)
5. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10 (+6)
6. Ayashimon - 6/10 (Non-Mover)
7. Vampire Knight - 6/10 (-3)
8. One Piece - 6/10 (+2)
9. Vagabond - 6/10 (-2)
10. Billy Bat - 5/10 (-7)
11. Monster - 5/10 (-6)
12. Pluto - 3/10 (Non-Mover)

Round 6:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10 (Non-Mover)
2. Zombie Loan - 8/10 (Non-Mover)
3. Monster - 7/10 (+8)
4. Vampire Knight - 7/10 (+3)
5. Ayashimon - 7/10 (+1)
6. Billy Bat - 6/10 (+4)
7. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 6/10 (-4)
8. Fabricant 100 - 6/10 (-4)
9. One Piece - 6/10 (-1)
10. Ice-Head Gill - 5/10 (-5)
11. Vagabond - 4/10 (-2)
12. Pluto - 3/10 (Non-Mover)

Round 7:
1. Monster - 9/10
2. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
3. Zombie Loan - 8/10
4. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 7/10
5. Fabricant 100 - 7/10
6. Vampire Knight - 7/10
7. Ayashimon - 7/10
8. Billy Bat - 6/10
9. Ice-Head Gill - 5/10
10. Vagabond - 4/10
11. One Piece - 4/10
12. Pluto - 3/10

Round 8:
1. Monster - 9/10
2. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
3. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
4. Fabricant 100 - 7/10
5. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
6. Vampire Knight - 7/10
7. Zombie Loan - 7/10
8. Ayashimon - 7/10
9. One Piece - 6/10
10. Vagabond - 6/10
11. Billy Bat - 6/10
12. Pluto - 5/10

Round 9:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
2. Zombie Loan - 8/10
3. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
4. Vampire Knight - 7/10
5. Billy Bat - 7/10
6. Pluto - 7/10
7. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
8. Monster - 6/10
9. One Piece - 6/10
10. Vagabond - 6/10
11. Ayashimon - 5/10
12. Fabricant 100 - 5/10

Round 10:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
2. Monster - 8/10
3. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
4. Ice-Head Gill - 8/10
5. Zombie Loan - 8/10
6. Vampire Knight - 7/10
7. Fabricant 100 - 6/10
8. Billy Bat - 6/10
9. Ayashimon - 5/10
10. One Piece - 5/10
11. Vagabond - 4/10
12. Pluto - 3/10

Round 11:
1. Zombie Loan - 9/10
2. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 9/10
3. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
4. Monster - 8/10
5. Billy Bat - 8/10
6. Ice-Head Gill - 8/10
7. One Piece - 7/10
8. Fabricant 100 - 7/10
9. Pluto - 6/10
10. Vampire Knight - 6/10
11. Vagabond - 6/10
12. Ayashimon - 6/10

Round 12:
1. Zombie Loan - 9/10
2. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
3. Fabricant 100 - 9/10
4. Monster - 8/10
5. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
6. Billy Bat - 8/10
7. Vagabond - 7/10
8. Pluto - 7/10
9. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
10. Vampire Knight - 6/10
11. One Piece - 6/10
12. Ayashimon - 5/10

Round 13:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
2. Zombie Loan - 9/10
3. Fabricant 100 - 9/10
4. Monster - 8/10
5. Blade: Blood Allies (Chapter 1) - 8/10 - Not a bad first chapter at all, it's got a good tone and style imo.
6. Pluto - 8/10
7. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
8. Billy Bat - 8/10
9. Vampire Knight - 7/10
10. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
11. Ayashimon - 7/10
12. One Piece - 6/10
13. Sadistic Beauty - 6/10 (Chapter 1) - 6/10 - Tbf to the first chapter, it looks like it's doing it's thing okay so far.
14. Vagabond - 6/10

Round 14:
1. Pluto - 9/10
2. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
3. Zombie Loan - 9/10
4. Vagabond - 9/10
5. Fabricant 100 - 9/10
6. Vampire Knight - 8/10
7. Blade: Blood Allies (Chapter 2) - 8/10
8. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
9. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
10. Monster - 7/10
11. One Piece - 6/10
12. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 2) - 6/10
13. Ayashimon - 5/10
14. Billy Bat - 4/10

Round 15:
1. Zombie Loan - 9/10
2. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 9/10
3. Fabricant 100 - 9/10
4. Blade: Blood Allies (Final Chapter) - 8/10 - It's a shame that it got cancelled tbh.
5. Ice-Head Gill - 8/10
6. Vampire Knight - 8/10
7. The Promised Neverland - 8/10
8. Pluto - 7/10
9. Vagabond - 7/10
10. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 3) - 6/10
11. Ayashimon - 6/10
12. One Piece - 5/10
13. Billy Bat - 4/10
14. Monster - 3/10

Round 16:
1. Vampire Knight - 9/10
2. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood
3. Zombie Loan - 9/10
4. Blame! (Chapter 1) - 8/10
5. The Promised Neverland - 8/10
6. Ice-Head Gill - 8/10
7. Love Only The Body (Chapter 1) - 8/10
8. Ex-Arm (Chapter 1) - 7/10
9. Weakness (Chapter 1) - 7/10
10. Pluto - 7/10
11. Fabricant 100 - 7/10
12. Lilith (Chapter 1) - 7/10
13. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 4) - 6/10
14. Talk Dirty To Me (Chapter 1) - 6/10
15. Ayashimon - 6/10
16. Spice Girls (Chapter 1) - 6/10
17. One Piece - 5/10
18. Toy xx Box (Chapter 1) - 5/10
19. When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine (Chapter 1) - 4/10
20. Monster - 4/10
21. Vagabond - 4/10
22. Martial Master Asumi (Chapter 1) - 4/10
23. Billy Bat - 3/10

Round 17:
1. Pluto - 9/10
2. The Promised Neverland - 8/10
3. Monster - 8/10
4. Vampire Knight - 8/10
5. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood - 8/10
6. Love Only The Body (Chapter 2) - 8/10
7. Spice Girls (Chapter 2) - 8/10
8. Weakness (Chapter 2) - 8/10
9. Blame! (Chapter 2) - 8/10
10. Talk Dirty To Me (Chapter 2) - 7/10
11. Lilith (Chapter 2) - 7/10
12. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
13. Ex-Arm (Chapter 2) - 7/10
14. Zombie Loan - 6/10
15. Martial Master Asumi (Chapter 2) - 6/10
16. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 5) - 6/10
17. Ayashimon - 6/10
18. When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine (Chapter 2) - 6/10
19. One Piece - 5/10
20. Fabricant 100 - 5/10
21. Toy xx Box (Chapter 2) - 5/10
22. Billy Bat - 4/10
23. Vagabond - 4/10

Round 18:
1. Vampire Knight - 9/10 - It was extremely tight between the top two in particular for this round, but Vampire Knight edged it for me.
2. Pluto - 9/10
3. Weakness (Chapter 3) - 9/10
4. The Hunters Guild: Red Hood (Final Chapter) - 8/10 - A shame to see it end.
5. Love Only The Body (Chapter 3) - 8/10
6. Blame! (Chapter 3) - 8/10
7. Martial Master Asumi (Chapter 3) - 7/10
8. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 6) - 7/10
9. Billy Bat - 7/10
10. Zombie Loan - 7/10
11. Ice-Head Gill - 7/10
12. Ex-Arm (Chapter 3) - 7/10
13. Spice Girls (Chapter 3) - 7/10
14. Talk Dirty To Me (Chapter 3) - 7/10
15. Toy xx Box (Chapter 3) - 7/10
16. The Promised Neverland - 6/10
17. Ayashimon - 6/10
18. One Piece - 6/10
19. Lilith (Chapter 3) - 6/10
20. Monster - 5/10
21. When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine (Chapter 3) - 5/10
22. Fabricant 100 - 4/10
23. Vagabond - 2/10

Round 19:
1. Monster - 9/10
2. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
3. Vampire Knight - 9/10
4. Weakness (Final Chapter) - 9/10 - A shame to see it go, in a weird sort of way lol.
5. Pluto - 9/10
6. Vagabond - 8/10
7. Ayashimon - 8/10
8. Ice-Head Gill - 8/10
9. Zombie Loan - 8/10
10. Love Only The Body (Chapter 4) - 8/10
11. Billy Bat - 7/10
12. Blame! (Chapter 4) - 7/10
13. Martial Master Asumi (Chapter 4) - 7/10
14. One Piece - 7/10
15. Talk Dirty To Me (Chapter 4) - 7/10
16. Spice Girls (Chapter 4) - 7/10
17. Ex-Arm (Chapter 4) - 6/10
18. When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine (Chapter 4) - 6/10
19. Toy xx Box (Chapter 4) - 5/10
20. Lilith (Chapter 4) - 5/10
21. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 7) - 4/10
22. Fabricant 100 - 4/10 - No offense to anyone that likes this chapter of Fabricant 100, but to me the writing was very dumbed down, and I normally don't mind some dumbed down stuff, but this was toddler level writing imo. Decent ending though.

Round 20:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
2. Blame! (Chapter 5) - 9/10 - I like the idea of The Authorities.
3. Monster - 9/10
4. Vampire Knight - 9/10
5. Ex-Arm (Chapter 5) - 8/10
6. Zombie Loan - 8/10
7. Pluto - 8/10
8. Spice Girls (Final Chapter) - 8/10 - It's a decent little series imo. It might spice up your life in the Manga world.
9. Vagabond - 8/10
10. Billy Bat - 7/10
11. When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine (Chapter 5) - 7/10
12. Love Only The Body (Final Chapter) - 7/10 - Again sad to see it go.
13. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 8) - 6/10
14. Ayashimon - 6/10
15. Lilith (Chapter 5) - 6/10
16. Talk Dirty To Me (Chapter 5) - 6/10
17. Martial Master Asumi (Chapter 5) - 6/10
18. Toy xx Box (Chapter 5) - 5/10
19. One Piece - 4/10
20. Fabricant 100 - 4/10
21. Ice-Head Gill (Final Chapter) - 3/10 - Despite where I've placed it in this particular round, I will still be sad to see it go as I thought that it was developing into a tight series that was an underdog in Shounen Jump, unfortunately the cancellation of the series seems to have made the writer rush the ending which is understandable, but also a shame. If you like Vikings, Fantasy and Adventure series then I would still recommend checking this series out, you can tell that the Author put a lot of effort into this series.

Round 21:
1. The Promised Neverland - 9/10
2. Monster - 9/10
3. Blame! (Chapter 6) - 9/10
4. Final Fantasy: Lost Stranger (Chapter 1) - 8/10
5. Baroque: The Missing Paradigm (Chapter 1) - 8/10
6. Pluto - 7/10
7. Vampire Knight - 7/10
8. Talk Dirty To Me (Chapter 6) - 7/10
9. When The Villainess Meets The Crazy Heroine (Chapter 6) - 7/10
10. Vagabond - 7/10
11. Lilith (Chapter 6) - 7/10
12. Zombie Loan - 6/10
13. Martial Master Asumi (Chapter 6) - 6/10
14. Ayashimon - 6/10
15. After War Gundam X (Chapter 1) - 6/10
16. Fabricant 100 - 6/10
17. Sadistic Beauty (Chapter 9) - 6/10
18. Ex-Arm (Chapter 6) - 5/10
19. Toy xx Box (Chapter 6) - 5/10
20. Billy Bat - 4/10
21. One Piece - 3/10
22. The Horizon (Chapter 1) - 2/10
23. Superman: Red Son (Chapter 1) - 2/10 - The first chapter felt like it was trying to be too serious in tone, I get that DC put a spin on the formula which I respect, but imo the first chapter didn't balance it out very well with the goofy/lighter tone of Superman compared to heroes like Batman and Green Arrow which are the darker Superheroes.


I will try to update it regularly, for anyone that cares anyway.

Hopefully there's a series from this lot that you guys will be able to enjoy.