[LaLaLand]

Anyone else think it should have been the other way around with Liam solo and Tom in the group?

I just think that Liam would have shone as a solo and now may be forgotten about really :/

[Jords]

Yes!

[King Gizzard]

Liam is just so..boring

the voice was dull

[MeMyselfAndI]

Tom is amazing

[King Gizzard]

If toms the little one who can dance then he should be on his own, he'll have big energetic performances, whereas he'd be limited in a group as some of them (zain for example) can't dance at all

[Lucy.]

No. Tom is epic. Liam is BOO

[LaLaLand]

I hate Tom, he's too cocksure. I LOL'd when his audition turned into a music exam because he was so, so confident he'd sail through.

[Callum]

I agree, he was better than Tom. I hate Tom's accent, I hear loads of people speaking like him near me, it really grates on me.

[Tom]

Tom needs some clearasil

[Chels]

Originally Posted by Jonnii

I hate Tom, he's too cocksure. I LOL'd when his audition turned into a music exam because he was so, so confident he'd sail through.

He is, a few of my mates know him and he's a knob. Boosh said the same thing too.

And yeah I agree, Liam's amazing and his voice is far too powerful for a boyband.

[taylorisme]

i don't like tom but he probably wont get through so i don't mind. i have no idea why they put liam in a group like he even got a standing ovation from simon at his audition and girls obviously love him so haven't got a clue what they must be thinking there. maybe they want a group to win this year?

[30stone]

Tom isawful.


The typical big headed no talent lol.


Liam was better. i dont like either particularly tho..

[LidlSistA]

That was purely tactical, none of them, would have got thru to live show, boys category too strong, at least liam and harry will get a shot now with the groups

[taylorisme]

yeah i'm kinda thinking they wanted a group of 5 biebers because they probably want a group to win and they know lil girls will love them

[Lee.]

I think Liam is one of the better singers in the whole competition and to just include him in some supergroup as an afterthought is kinda insulting!
Toim would have been a much better choice! The judges even said during his audition that he would be perfect for a boy band!

[joeysteele]

Liam is better than Tom at singing, Tom is a better performer,on balance I just would have put Liam through as Tom will struggle with many of the daft themed weeks such as swing week, diva week etc.
Instead of altering age limits its the themed weeks that should go and just have songs they can perform to their best presented in 'live' shows to the viewers.

[LidlSistA]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Liam is better than Tom at singing, Tom is a better performer,on balance I just would have put Liam through as Tom will struggle with many of the daft themed weeks such as swing week, diva week etc.
Instead of altering age limits its the themed weeks that should go and just have songs they can perform to their best presented in 'live' shows to the viewers.

But Tom is highly unlikely to get thru to live shows and they know that. Liam was unlikely to either considering the competition, but now Liam is likely to go thru to live shows and thats why they did that im sure

[red]

liam looks a bit like lloyd from last year and they both have a similar style IMO but yeah he's still better than desperate tom X(

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by LidlSistA

But Tom is highly unlikely to get thru to live shows and they know that. Liam was unlikely to either considering the competition, but now Liam is likely to go thru to live shows and thats why they did that im sure

Yes, I can go along with your view too.Very good point.

[LidlSistA]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Yes, I can go along with your view too.Very good point.

Cheers. I was like wtf at first but then I thought about it and it made sense