Quote:
Originally Posted by parmnion
Deducting 2 points for personal taste, when the games criteria is about good vocal.performances makes a mockery out he game imo...
Imo, the personal taste part should be the thing that doesnt effect the game too much, and a 2 point deduction for not liking the artist is harsh, especially when it's a game about vocal.performaces.
|
Well, tough quite frankly, this is how I'm marking them, as I said I said very clearly before the game even started that's how I would be doing it in a conversation with Kate, if she, you or anyone else thought that was a bad system they should have said it then. Here's the exchange below, you infact posted just after Kate had replied to me telling her how I'd be scroing them, why not mention it then? Or is it just because you're sore about the score I gave you this round?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Niamh.
So when we're judging these what is our criteria, are we just picking which songs we like best?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kate!
Marks out of ten please, based on these things.
If it fits the theme
How good a vocal performance it is
and how much you personally like the song.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Niamh.
Just had a quick look, some absolute tunes in there. My strategy with scoring is to mark out of 5 for vocals and the same for personal taste and if it doesn't fit the theme I'll deduct 4 points from the score I give
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kate!
Thanks Niamh. Look forward to reading them later  |
Quote:
Originally Posted by parmnion
A show tonight?
|