[Strictly Jake]

I hope this is true

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Why are they just recycling judges every year

It doesn't quite seem to have occurred to them that the show is so bad because everything about it is old. They don't understand the concept of "new".

[Ninastar]

oh **** off sharon

[_Tom_]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

It doesn't quite seem to have occurred to them that the show is so bad because everything about it is old. They don't understand the concept of "new".

Swimming in this tea

[Jack_]

can they hurry up and confirm this plz because it's the most perfect panel of all the ex-judges. Like literally, you cannot do better than this

I've wanted this panel for years, please make it a reality

[joeysteele]

Good one if this is confirmed,great for me.

[Shaun]

Sharon was dull af on her last stint but I see her "legendary/drama" status is still being flogged like a dead horse.
Nicole is 3 annoying catchphrases in rapid succession.

Only happy for Louis.

[Marsh.]

Louis is as bad as Nicole if not worse for his awful catchphrases.

[LaLaLand]

Ugh wanted Mel B back, she was a brilliant judge.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Jonnii

Ugh wanted Mel B back, she was a brilliant judge.

My god, when she told that group with 5672 members that they gave their best ever performance after they gave their worst performance in the sing off.

[LaLaLand]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

My god, when she told that group with 5672 members that they gave their best ever performance after they gave their worst performance in the sing off.

Hahaha I'm not saying she was always right but she wasn't afraid of being "the baddie" and opening her gob like Cheralien Tweedy.

[Ross.]

Mel B's unnecessary hate on Fleur did not go unnoticed

[Heaven = Winner]

omg yes! Living for muthas Sharon & Nicole

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

It doesn't quite seem to have occurred to them that the show is so bad because everything about it is old. They don't understand the concept of "new".

Yes because new host, judges and judges homes format was so successful last year.

[Guuki]

Yes! I loved Nicole, I loved Sharron and Louis just has to be there. With Simon it's going to be the best panel of all the series I've wathed so far (since 2012).

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by _LucasMichael_

Yes because new host, judges and judges homes format was so successful last year.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by _LucasMichael_

Yes because new host, judges and judges homes format was so successful last year.

Wasn't really new though was it?

Flack, Murs, Cowell, Cheryl, judges houses etc are old and have been part of the show for a number of years.

Ora was fine but hiring someone like Nick bloody Grimshaw was never going to be successful.

Maybe I should qualify, new AND good.

[Lostie!]

I actually want the show to return to it's roots as much as possible (3 judges to rule out deadlock copouts, only room auditions, no Sunday show, normal Bootcamp, finales that aren't overblown and boring as ****). My enjoyment of the show has lessened because the changes they make in an effort to make it new and fresh are always, without exception, absolute ****e.

It was fine as it was before they started changing everything.

[Pete.]

Keep the Sunday show though

[Lostie!]

I hate it, it was great when they used to have it all on one night imo.

[Marsh.]

Time to axe it and give a new format a chance tbh.

12 years is long enough for any show like this.

[Ross.]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

I actually want the show to return to it's roots as much as possible (3 judges to rule out deadlock copouts, only room auditions, no Sunday show, normal Bootcamp, finales that aren't overblown and boring as ****). My enjoyment of the show has lessened because the changes they make in an effort to make it new and fresh are always, without exception, absolute ****e.

It was fine as it was before they started changing everything.

Although I'm a lowkey fan of the drama at the six seat challenge

[Ross.]

Nicole has practically been confirmed

http://www.digitalspy.com/tv/the-x-f...-ditched-cats/

[Jack_]

please please please make this panel a reality

I actually think if they were all up for it again this could go the same way as BGT's and be a long-lasting one. The dynamic will be perfect IMO

[Jack.]

Originally Posted by Jack_

please please please make this panel a reality

I actually think if they were all up for it again this could go the same way as BGT's and be a long-lasting one. The dynamic will be perfect IMO

Simon and Louis will stay until the end of x factor now so will dermot. I can see Nicole staying for as long as Simon wants her. It will be Sharon that will be the only that might only last a year again because the producers on the talk might get annoyed if Sharon is missing loads of their shows.